529 Plans: How to Choose One (and Whether You Should)
A 529 plan is the best tool most parents have for college savings: contributions grow tax-free, withdrawals for qualified education expenses are tax-free, and many states give you a tax break on contributions. It's about as close to a "free lunch" as the tax code gets — for one specific goal.
But there's a nuance most parents miss, and it's the single most important thing to know before you fund one.
How a 529 Works
You contribute after-tax dollars, they grow tax-free, and as long as you spend the money on qualified education expenses (tuition, room and board, books, and now up to a limited amount of K-12 and student loan repayment), you never pay tax on the growth.
The state tax deduction is the cherry on top: many states let you deduct contributions, effectively an instant return in the year you contribute.
The One Rule Most Parents Get Wrong
Fund your own retirement before the 529.
It feels counterintuitive — and a little selfish — but it's mathematically airtight: your child can borrow for college. You cannot borrow for retirement. There are loans, grants, scholarships, and work-study for education. There is none of that for retirement.
A parent who fully funds a 529 but underfunds their own retirement has effectively transferred their future insecurity to their child — who will one day have to support them. The family-first provider's blind spot is exactly this. Max your 401(k) and IRA first, then fund the 529.
How to Choose a Plan
You're not limited to your own state's plan — you can use any state's, though the tax deduction usually only applies to your home state's plan. The decision:
1. Start with your own state's plan. If your state offers a deduction, that's usually the tiebreaker — an instant tax savings that outweighs small differences in fees.
2. If no deduction, compare on fees. 529 fees vary meaningfully. Low-cost index-based plans are the right default. A plan charging 0.5%+ is quietly eating your returns.
3. Look at the investment options. Age-based portfolios (which automatically get more conservative as college approaches) are the sane default. You want simple, low-cost index options, not exotic active funds.
4. Check the contribution limits and flexibility. High contribution limits are nice. More important: can you change beneficiaries (e.g., to a sibling) without penalty? Good plans allow it.
What If College Doesn't Happen?
The old worry — "what if my kid doesn't go to college?" — has mostly been addressed. You can:
- Change the beneficiary to another family member
- Use up to $35,000 to fund a Roth IRA for the beneficiary (as of recent rules)
- Withdraw non-qualified funds (paying taxes plus a 10% penalty on the earnings only)
The flexibility is real. The "what if they don't go" objection is mostly outdated.
The Bottom Line
A 529 is a great tool for a specific goal — but it comes after your own retirement is funded. Start with your state's plan (for the deduction), prioritize low fees, use the age-based portfolio, and don't over-fund it at the expense of your own future.
Put on your own oxygen mask first. Fund retirement before college, then let the 529 do what it does best.
Your finances are unique. Let Alistair build a plan around your goals.
Get personalized financial guidance based on your actual numbers — free to start.
Try Alistair Free