The Sunk Cost Fallacy in Investing: Why You Can't Sell the Loser

Alistair TeamNovember 17, 20266 min read
Money Psychologysunk cost fallacyinvestingbehavioral financeloss aversion

You bought a stock at $100. It's now $60. You tell yourself you'll sell "when it gets back to even" — because selling now would mean accepting the loss, and accepting the loss means admitting the mistake.

This is the sunk cost fallacy, and it's one of the most expensive mental errors an investor can make. Let's unpack what's actually happening.

What a Sunk Cost Is

A sunk cost is money already spent that you can't get back. The $40/share you're down? That's gone. It's not "yours, temporarily misplaced." It's gone. The market doesn't remember — and doesn't care — what you paid.

The fallacy is treating that unrecoverable past as if it should influence your present decision. "I've already lost $40, so I should hold" makes no more sense than "I already paid for this movie, so I should stay even though it's terrible." The $40 and the movie ticket are both sunk. The only question that matters is: what's the best use of this money going forward?

Why "Get Back to Even" Is a Trap

"Get back to even" feels like a plan. It's not — it's an emotion with a spreadsheet attached. Here's the logic it hides:

It assumes the loser will recover. It might not. It might go to zero. "Back to even" is a hope, not a forecast.

It ignores opportunity cost. While your money sits in a declining stock waiting to break even, it's not sitting in whatever would grow faster. The real cost isn't the loss you're avoiding — it's the gain you're missing. This is the same dynamic as holding losers too long — the paper loss feels survivable, but the opportunity cost is invisible.

It makes the past the boss of the future. "I paid $100" is history. "What will this do next?" is the only question that matters. The market doesn't owe you $100 back because you once paid it.

The Reframe That Actually Works

Ask yourself one question, and answer it honestly:

"If I had this money in cash today, would I buy this exact position at today's price?"

If the answer is no — if you wouldn't buy it now — then holding it is the same as buying it now. You're choosing, every day, to own it. Not selling is a decision. And if you wouldn't make that decision from a clean slate, you're making it for a bad reason: because of what you paid in the past.

This reframe works for stocks, for a bad fund you keep holding, even for a house that's become a money pit. The past payment is irrelevant. The future is the only thing on the table.

How to Protect Yourself

Write your exit criteria before you buy. "I'll sell if the thesis breaks" or "I'll re-evaluate if it drops 20%." Deciding in advance, when you're calm, is how you override the emotion that shows up later. It's the same logic as an Investment Policy Statement.

Harvest the loss deliberately. If the position is in a taxable account, selling at a loss isn't just freeing the capital — it's a tax-loss harvesting opportunity. The loss you're avoiding booking can actually save you money.

Don't look at your cost basis. Delete the "total return since purchase" column. It's showing you sunk costs, and sunk costs are noise.

The Bottom Line

The money you've already lost is gone, and no amount of waiting changes that. The only question is what the money you still have should be doing.

Stop asking "how do I get back to even?" and start asking "if I had this in cash today, would I buy it?" The answer is usually no — and that's your answer.

Your finances are unique. Let Alistair build a plan around your goals.

Get personalized financial guidance based on your actual numbers — free to start.

Try Alistair Free